So, I think my core problem really is in the picture I need to take in the first place. I'm going to pull out my real camera and see what it does. I think I just have way too much purple showing up with my current lights. I can get a normal picture by dimming my blues like Diana suggested. But, it looks kind of flat. Maybe I could start with that one and edit it.
Anyway, this is my before and after...
Before
After
(BTW, I'm kind of half in the middle of moving stuff around, so artistically not where I want it yet anyway...aside from the bad pic).