Recent content by tankgirl

If what you mean is that any tank threads will have to go there, I'm against it.

Tooloud, I think you're not reading all of the posts? Many others in this thread have clearly stated that moving Robs thread the way it was done, was wrong in their opinion, too. Alf, I said nice things about you, but your aversarial histrionics aren't helping. And, trying to bully me into...

Again, Tooloud, I just have a very different opinion.

I gotta disagree. Alf's attitude seems to be that we should all just shut up and accept his right to do whatever he wants without regard for fairness or singling one thread out.

Crak, Lucky, you're both right. Tooloud, again, the reason I don't like a members tank forum where All pics HAVE to be put, is because it's going to hurt the forum - guests browse Gen Discussion, then decide to stay based on what they see there.

Every thread is important to at least one person, if not more. Nobody's is more important. Rob's thread just happens to be a very popular thread, but that doesn't make it More important. The main discussion was about Rob's tank. Many questions in that thread about his techniques, equipment...

Tooloud, Yeah, there's a reason for other forums. But, the idea that ALL pictures belong in the photo forum is pretty awful. Pictures carry information even better than words do. I'm pretty sure that guests browse the Gen. Discussion forum first - then if they are intrigued by the threads...

Lucky, wise words - That sounds good with me but I will keep replying here if others post.

Tooloud, okay, but I just don't agree with you. I think our best model is a Gen. Discussion forum that has a lot of threads and a lot of new stuff (as well as recurring favorites that are brought back up). That's a great board. Scott, ditto. :)

Hi Scott, I respect your opinion. As for; even Tooloud admits; Everyone, this isn't just wasted space. We, in a discussion like this, form a consensus about what is right and what is wrong. Every word here is a vote for how things should be done. kennerd; THAT was truly funny...

jime, Thank you!!! Becca, Thanks for your kind words and you're the best! Thank you, wooddood! Trav, just for the record, I do like you. As for the histrionics, I think you did your part in contributing to that. But, you did the right thing - the decision to leave pic threads where...

TooLoud, that would be your pics of your tank in the Gen Discussion forum, right? But, Robs pics of his tank and corals belong in the Photography forum, right?

sorc, I've tried to explain this and will try one more time. I believe Rob's thread is a showcase for the forum - it's unquestionably one of the most popular threads on the entire site. I think it brings people to this place - new people, who see the thread and want to hang around because they...

Johnny, I'm sorry the GM thread got pulled into this thread. As I mentioned, it doesn't do much for me, but I completely respect and appreciate that it's important to you and many others and a valuable addition to the forum. I was only using it as an example of how rules were not evenly...

Cool!! Now, we need a new full tank shot and new thirds of the tank, and....