I got involved with a group buy from MarineDepotLive a couple of months ago. What a nightmare! about half the fish didn't even get shipped, of those that did get shipped, more than half went to the wrong person in another part of the Bay area. Everyone was lucky that he was honest, or we never would have known where that part of the order went. Approx 1/2 of the fish that we did get, died within 2 weeks, many within the 5 day guarantee time frame. It took more than a month to finally finish filling the order. Apparently, (according to them) they advertise lots of fish on their website, then when you order, they go out to the wholesalers and try to find the fish you ordered. Also adding to the problems was the fact that we ordered right after the 1st of the year, and apparently, many of the collectors are closed or not collecting for weather or other reasons during that time. I can say that they bent over backwards to finally make the order right with all of us, even threw in shipping & a few free fish to make up for the inconveniences, but overall, it was an unpleasant ordeal, one I'm not looking forward to trying again soon.