Quantcast
Calcium/Alkalinity problems

Become a Sponsor Our Sponsors
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 27

Thread: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

  1. #1
    Midas Blenny
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Silver Spring, MD
    Posts
    92

    Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Hi everyone. I'm about 5 months in to my first salt water tank.
    From the beginning I've had an issue with my Calcium being high... usually around 540-560. I FINALLY just bought an alkalinity test because everything I read shows the two tied together. My alkalinity is a little low at 2.28 mEq/L. pH stays a stable 8.2 most of the time.

    I'm trying to learn more about these water parameters and some of the articles I have read are difficult to understand. In 5 months I have had very little coraline algae growth. I now have one hard coral which came on a rock I bought for its combination of mushrooms and zoas, so I feel its now very important that I figure this out! That coral has lost most of its color in the two weeks I have had it

    So... can anyone explain to me the relationship between calcium and alkalinity in more simple terms? How can I raise my alkalinity? I would think that the calcium would lower with use by coral, coraline, etc. but why is my alkalinity low?

    Also... can these parameters affect algae growth in any way?

  2. #2
    Bryozoan Clonefarmer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    Springfield, MA
    Posts
    48

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Quote Originally Posted by na06003 View Post
    So... can anyone explain to me the relationship between calcium and alkalinity in more simple terms? How can I raise my alkalinity? I would think that the calcium would lower with use by coral, coraline, etc. but why is my alkalinity low?
    I can't explain the relationship too well, but here is a basic explanation of why the Alkalinity drops faster than Calcium. Both Calcium and Alkalinity are used to make Calcium Carbonate. The ratio used is roughly 20 ppm Calcium to 1 point dkh. Since there is allot more Calcium than Alkalinity, the Alkalinity appears to drop faster.

  3. #3
    Bryozoan Clonefarmer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    Springfield, MA
    Posts
    48

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Here is an article that explains the relationship better. Calcium and Alkalinity by Randy Holmes-Farley

  4. #4
    Wannabe Guru cheeks69's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Northeast
    Posts
    8,213

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    If your not using a two part cal/alk supplement then I suspect the issue is your salt mix. Which test kits are you using ? Have you tested your magnesium levels ? Which salt mix are you using ?
    I would suggest you test your freshly mixed salt before adding it to your tank.

    Here's more good info:

    Understanding Calcium and Alkalinity

    Robert


    My Cube

    “A spirit is manifest in the laws of the Universe—a spirit vastly superior to that of man, and one in the face of which we with our modest powers must feel humble.” Albert Einstein

  5. #5
    Midas Blenny
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Silver Spring, MD
    Posts
    92

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Thanks so much for the help!

    The test kits I am using are API calcium and Salifert alkalinity/KH. My salt is Coralife. I have not tested mag levels. Would mag also affect calcium and alk?

    I am doing a water change today. I will test my fresh mixed before adding to the tank!!!

  6. #6
    Bryozoan Clonefarmer's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2010
    Location
    Springfield, MA
    Posts
    48

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Quote Originally Posted by na06003 View Post
    Thanks so much for the help!

    The test kits I am using are API calcium and Salifert alkalinity/KH. My salt is Coralife. I have not tested mag levels. Would mag also affect calcium and alk?

    I am doing a water change today. I will test my fresh mixed before adding to the tank!!!
    Magnesium plays a very important role alongside Calcium and Alkalinity.

    Here is an Article about Magnesium: DIY Magnesium supplement for the Reef Aquarium by Randy Holmes-Farley

  7. #7
    Val
    Val is offline
    Neon dottyback Val's Avatar
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Tulsa, OK
    Posts
    669

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    I agree test your next batch of saltwater and re-calibrate your refractometer also. good luck

  8. #8
    Scopas Tang magnetar68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Orinda, CA
    Posts
    442

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    With the API Calcium test it is important to shake bottle #2 for 10 seconds before using it.

    You will need to read those articles to get a better understanding of the relationship between Ca, Mg, and Alkalinity, but the concepts are very simple although rarely are they explained simply.

    If you started with normal sea water (or a good salt mix), you will have water with a bunch of stuff in it. Most of it is table salt: Sodium Chloride. But there are many other "ions" in this soup we call sea water. A big one is Calcium. Another big one is Magnesium. There is also a lot of dissolved Carbon Dioxide (CO2) from the atmosphere and other sources. This dissolved CO2 takes a few forms, but the most important for us as reef keepers is Carbonate (CO3) and Bi-Carbonate (HCO3). This makes up the majority of what we call Alkalinity (there are other lesser contributers). Alkalinity trips up a lot of people because we want to think of it as a measure of an amount of stuff in the tank water. The problem is that Alkalinity is only indirectly a measurement of stuff in water. Technically, alkalinity is a measurement of the ability of a solution to neutralize acids. How often do we need to think of something that measures the "ability" of something to do something? So the concept is a little abstract. But here's the main idea:

    Corals create their hard skeletons by taking the Calcium and the Carbonate in the water to make Calcium Carbonate (CaCO3)[into the aragonite form of CaCO]. The corals in our tank are therefore constantly removing Ca and Carbonate from the salt water. This removal means the ion soup is changing. As this ion soup changes, so does the chemistry of the salt water. If you take out too much Calcium, corals don't have the raw materials they need to make their hard skeletons. If you take out too much Carbonate (CO3), then they also don't have raw material, but more importantly, the sea water losses it's ability to neutralize acids. Since the decomposing food and fecal matter generates a lot of acids, the pH in the water will start to go down (pH is essentially a measure of acidity). This is deadly for most of the organisms in the tank.

    Magnesium's importance is a little more complicated, but Mg is a rather large atom [edit: meant to say Mg2+ is almost as large as Ca2+] that is similar to Ca in some ways. It therefore replaces Ca in some of the chemical reactions going on in the ion soup. There is also a lot more Mg in sea water than Ca, but the main thing Mg does is enable more Ca and CO3 to be in solution than would be there if there was no Mg. This is important because with Mg in the water the corals have more raw material to build there skeletons and sea water can better neutralize acids and maintain a constant pH.

    The main idea is to keep these three things in balance. Most recommends keeping Ca around 400-450ppm, Mg around 1300 ppm, and Alkalinity around 8dkH. Here is a good calculator that visually shows the target range for balancing these things in reef tanks: 'Reef Chemistry Calculator FV'
    Last edited by magnetar68; 03-05-2011 at 06:29 PM. Reason: corrected statement on Mg size

  9. #9
    Wannabe Guru cheeks69's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2003
    Location
    Northeast
    Posts
    8,213

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Excellent explanation Raymo
    Robert


    My Cube

    “A spirit is manifest in the laws of the Universe—a spirit vastly superior to that of man, and one in the face of which we with our modest powers must feel humble.” Albert Einstein

  10. #10
    Sailfin Marlin steved13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Treasure Island, Florida
    Posts
    7,760

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    +1
    Steve



    Steve's 250 Gallon


    250 Gallon Deep Dimension, Started 4/28/11, AI SOL Super Blue 4 modules, 50 gallon acrylic sump, 2X Reeflo Super Dart Gold return pumps, Emperor Aquatics 50W HO UV sterilizer,GHL Profilux 3.1NEX Controller, 2X Vortech MP40WES w/battery backup, GHL Profilux 4 channel dosing pump, JBJ Arctica 1/3hp chiller, Rena 300W smart heater ,Tunze Osmolator ATO, Reef Octopus BR110 Biopellet reactor, Reef Octopus MF 2000 media reactor for GAC, i-Tech 400 cone Skimmer, 2X Mocean 2000, 1" Sea Swirl, 160lbs Samoa pink #0 sand, 200+ lbs of live rock Closed 1/13/13

  11. #11
    Midas Blenny
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Silver Spring, MD
    Posts
    92

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Wow That makes a lot more sense. Thanks so much! It is so hard to try to control values when you don't understand why you are trying to control them. Articles make it sound so complicated! You gave a much better explanation! Maybe now when I read the more complicated articles I will have a better idea of what they are talking about...

    When I tested my make up water today I found that my salt seems to be the culprit. The new water in the bucket had a calcium reading of 540! Alkalinity was higher than my tank water though. It was around 4.68 mEq/L. pH was low at 7.8.

    Should I change the salt I've been using? Is there some sort of buffer I can use? What do you recommend?

  12. #12
    Sailfin Marlin steved13's Avatar
    Join Date
    Aug 2010
    Location
    Treasure Island, Florida
    Posts
    7,760

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Are you sure your test is accurate. That seems very high for any salt mix, anything is possible but that's very high.

    1 other thing if the test kit is accurate... Salt buckets are not homogenous, is it possible you found an area of the bucket where all the calcium is and the rest of the bucket has none? I think this is a long shot also, but just brainstorming.
    Steve



    Steve's 250 Gallon


    250 Gallon Deep Dimension, Started 4/28/11, AI SOL Super Blue 4 modules, 50 gallon acrylic sump, 2X Reeflo Super Dart Gold return pumps, Emperor Aquatics 50W HO UV sterilizer,GHL Profilux 3.1NEX Controller, 2X Vortech MP40WES w/battery backup, GHL Profilux 4 channel dosing pump, JBJ Arctica 1/3hp chiller, Rena 300W smart heater ,Tunze Osmolator ATO, Reef Octopus BR110 Biopellet reactor, Reef Octopus MF 2000 media reactor for GAC, i-Tech 400 cone Skimmer, 2X Mocean 2000, 1" Sea Swirl, 160lbs Samoa pink #0 sand, 200+ lbs of live rock Closed 1/13/13

  13. #13
    Nemo Frankie's Avatar
    Join Date
    Feb 2004
    Location
    AStrangerInAStrangeLand
    Posts
    14,987

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Very well said Raymo
    My current thread,
    http://www.reefsanctuary.com/forums/...-build-17.html
    If we ignore the environment
    maybe it will just go away....

  14. #14
    Scopas Tang magnetar68's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Orinda, CA
    Posts
    442

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    In terms of your specific question about what to do about these values, the first thing you need to do when a value is out of normal range is consider that the test is flawed. This is often user error (not reading the result correctly or doing the test differently than prescribed) but sometimes it's a bad test kit.

    In order to keep a reef aquarium in balance, I think you need four kits: Salinity, Calcium, Alkalinity, and Magnesium. Looks like you have two of the four, so that's a good start. For Salinity, it's not really a kit, but an instrument. Personally, I never had any luck with the plastic hydrometers. I could never get the bubbles out or a repeatable measurement, so I bought a $49 Marine Depot refractomer. This instrument is OK and will get you in the ballpark.

    Step 1. Make sure you are mixing your salt to the proper salinity. The container might tell you what the Ca, Alk, and Mg should be at this reference salinity. Once you know that is correct, you can address your tank issues. It does not make sense to fix the tank parameters if what is really making it out of whack is the water changes. If your LFS is willing to double check the Ca and Alk in your change water, that might give you some confidence in it. And yes, if your salt is off return it. This is one area I spend more money (although more money does not always mean better salt, in general it does: purer ingredients such as pharma grade cost more for the manufacturer). Also, sometimes our source water is the source of the issues. If you are using tap water or old RO or DI filters, this can be the source of extra ions.

    Step 2. You are getting a high Ca reading, so you are not sure if your Calcium kit is right. If you are sure you are following the directions exactly, you can either buy another brand (e.g., Salifert), or take it to your LFS and test their water with it. They should know their value with their kit and you can compare the two. BTW, The API Ca kit is a good brand (I use it), but your particular bottles could be bad for some reason.

    Step 3. If your salt mix is OK and your test kit is correct, then somehow your Ca is getting larger, not smaller. If you have been dosing Ca then this is likely the source. If you have not been dosing, then my thinking is that Step 1 or 2 is still an issue.

    Normally, reefers will need to dose Ca and Alkalinity. Some get away without dosing Magnesium by using a high quality salt and weekly water changes of sufficient volume. This means they get the Mg they need from the water changes. I have too many obligations for weekly water changes, so I do monthly. This means I need to keep an eye on my Mg and dose it, but I don't need to dose it as much as Ca and Alk.

    Step 4. The trick to most major water quality and balance issues is larger (50%) water changes a few weeks in a row -- assuming you are using a good salt that has the proper ionic balance. Either way, between these changes you will need to keep an eye on things. If Ca is low, you need to add it. If it's too high, then don't. The corals will consume it. Same with Alkalinity.

    Personally, I use SeaChem Reef Builder for Alkalinity, SeaCHem Reef Advantage Calcium for Ca, and on occasion Reef Advantage Magnesium for Mg. I mix them in my RO/DI top off water a couple of times a week using the beginner instructions and this keeps things in balance. Honestly, the sheer number of products is overwhelming. Until I understood the chemistry, I had no idea what the difference was between them. If used as directed the majority will work to some degree, although there are potential side effects depending on the actual chemicals in a particular product since they add ions in addition to the Ca, CO3, and Mg we want to add. But again, frequent and sufficient water changes can usually keep these things in check.

  15. #15
    Midas Blenny
    Join Date
    Apr 2010
    Location
    Silver Spring, MD
    Posts
    92

    Re: Calcium/Alkalinity problems

    Thanks for laying it out in parts for me. I do have a refractometer and have tested for calcium and alkalinity. I bought the fourth piece today: a Mg test kit. Mg reading is around 1270.

    I will try to test my Calcium test kit against another to see if it is off for some reason.

    So my understanding is that I need to be dosing for alkalinity and mag and wait for corals to use up the excess calcium. Correct?

Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •