To Clam or Not To Clam

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
So, I really, really love clams. My tank is over a year old and I had a gorgeous blue maxima I lost after about 6-8 months. I then tried a small Derasa I lost after only a few weeks. I have no idea why I lost either one.

My water parameters are typically pretty good at about 420 calcium and 9 alkalinity. They fluctuate a bit, but not too much. I do 20% water changes weekly and I think that helps keep them in line.

Liveaquaria just sent me a notice that they have 5" Deresa clams in stock, which is probably what I would try since Deresa are the hardiest and bigger is hardier.

Both of my prior clams were before my LEDs. I'm wondering if my lighting was weak? I had them in the substrate. Would my clams do better under LEDs?

Should I try again or is trying again just going to kill the clam because clearly I'm doing something wrong even if I don't know what it is?
 

nanoreefing4fun

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
Pat - I would think your new leds would be better at supporting a clam & would give it another go...

One key I have read.. is to not get one too small, as their survival rate is low, I would look for one at least 3" in size.

See what others think...

the only other key I know is stability alk & cal
 

nanoreefing4fun

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
Here is a good read too...

http://www.liveaquaria.com/PIC/article.cfm?aid=117

Giant Clams for Beginners: Beautiful, Hardy & Beneficial

Drs. Foster & Smith Educational Staff




a-giant-clam-derasa.jpg
a-giant-clams-title.gif

dot_clear.gif
If provided the proper conditions, giant clams are a great choice not only for the beginner reef aquarist, but even for the most advanced reef aquarists, offering beauty, biological benefits as well as biological diversity. Proper lighting, water movement, trace elements and placement of the giant clams will ensure the health of these fascinating invertebrates.
The clams of interest are of the genus Tridacna. These beautiful clams include: T. maxima, T. crocea, T. squamosa and T. derasa. There is amazing variation in color and pattern within these species, some resembling living pieces of art, making Tridacna clams highly desirable.

Benefits to your aquarium
Besides their beauty, clams provide another important benefit to a saltwater aquarium: biological filtration. Their superior filtering capabilities offer added stability and nutrient control in a closed aquarium system.

Excess nutrients lead to problems with low pH, algae, and cyanobacteria blooms - general poor water conditions that ultimately affect the health of all inhabitants within the aquarium.

Clams constantly filter nutrients such as ammonia and nitrate from the water thereby reducing the biological load and lowering the overall nitrate level in the aquarium, improving water conditions.

Environmental Requirements

Lighting
Proper lighting is the most critical parameter essential to the well being of giant clams. Tridacna clams not only filter nutrients from the water to satisfy their dietary needs, but also employ algae cells within their mantle called zooxanthellae. These algae cells require light as well as nutrients from both the clam and the water to properly photosynthesize. The clam then utilizes the energy the algae cells produced through photosynthesis to aid in its growth.

Clams therefore require moderate to high lighting conditions, ideally supplied by power compact fluorescent fixtures or metal halide fixtures. If using fluorescent fixtures, simply place the clam closer to the light source.

Water Movement
Tridacna clams do not like strong, direct water currents. They prefer moderate, indirect water movement. Strong, direct water movement seems to inhibit the clam's ability to adjust the amount of water passing through it, affecting their ability to properly filter the water.



Target Levels for Trace Elements
Calcium levels should be maintained between 400 to 450 ppm with a pH of 8.1 to 8.4 and an 8 to 12 DKH. Giant clams use calcium and strontium to build their shells.
Strontium levels should be maintained between 6 to 10 ppm. Slightly higher levels of strontium have proven not to be harmful to most invertebrates, but it can encourage unsightly cyanobacteria outbreaks.
Iodine levels should be maintained between 0.04 and 0.08 ppm. Iodine helps break down oxygen produced by the zooxanthellae cells and prevents damage due to excessive light exposure, helping the clam maintain their bright coloration. If the clam shows poor coloration, test the iodine level.
Trace Elements
The three main trace elements giant clams require are calcium, strontium, and iodine. These elements should be present in the aquarium at or near levels found in nature. Regular water changes and routine supplementation replenish these trace elements. However, if an aquarium is heavily stocked or if aggressive chemical filtration is used, more frequent supplementation may be necessary.
Placement
Proper placement within your aquarium is the final aspect to consider when caring for Tridacna clams. After evaluating your lighting system and water movement within the aquarium, choose the proper location for your clam.

  • Place the clam so that the mantle is facing upward towards the light to maximize exposure to light. The mantle must be in full illumination in order to provide the clam with nutrients.
  • If a more powerful lighting system, like metal halides, are used on an aquarium 24 inches or less, these clams can be placed just about anywhere in the aquarium, as long as they are not blocked from the light.
  • If at any time the clam moves and is lying on its side, right the clam back to the upright position. Do this immediately or the clam will slowly starve to death.
  • Do not place the clam in a crevice where it may have difficulty fully opening its shell. Make sure the location is sturdy and offers enough room for the clam to grow.
  • Do not place the clam in an area that has strong, direct water movement.
Aquacultured Tridacna derasa
Tridacna clams are not only some of the most beautiful additions to a reef aquarium, but because of their superior filtering capabilities, they offer added stability and nutrient control to the reef aquarium. T. derasa clams are the best choice out of this genus. They are the hardiest of the Tridacna clams, and will adjust to a wide variety of conditions within most aquariums - making them ideal for beginners.

CLOSE-UP: Aquacultured Tridacna derasa



QUICK STATS
Care Level
: Moderate
Reef Compatible: Yes
Lighting: Moderate
Waterflow: Medium
Placement: Bottom, Middle
Water Conditions: 72-78° F, dKH 8-12, pH 8.1-8.4, sg 1.020-1.025
Color Form: Blue, Brown, Green, Yellow
Diet: Filter Feeder
Supplements: Calcium, Magnesium, Strontium, Trace Elements
Origin: Aquacultured, Cook Islands
Family: Tridacnidae

The Derasa Clam is the most widely available and hardy of the Tridacna clams. This species is one of the largest of the "giant" clams, and grows rapidly, reaching a maximum size of approximately 20 inches. Under the proper conditions, smaller Derasa Clams can double or triple their size in less than a year. Its mantle is a mixture of orange, yellow, blue, and black and white, and usually has a wavy striped or spotted pattern, usually with vivid blues and greens.
 

newo11

Well-Known Member
Pat - go for it! I've kept a 5 inch crocea for over a year under LED's. Your tank is mature enough to handle it and the key is to get a larger clam, as Glenn said. I also supplement with phyto daily but I don't think that's really necessary. I'm looking forward to seeing this in your tank!
 

DaveK

Well-Known Member
I don't see any reason not to get a clam in Pat's case. However, the article posted by nanoreefingforfun does have some errors in it. Clams are defiantly not a beginner livestock. The require high quality water, lighting and filtration. They also need to be in tanks where fish and other livestock are going to leave them alone.

Clams also don't do that much for biological filtration, and it's fairly easy to choke a clam if you really stir up the tank substrata.

Clams can be a great addition, but make sure you meet the requirements for them.
 

Wrangy

Acropora Nut
RS STAFF
PREMIUM
+1 to what Dave has just said. They're definitely not beginner animals and a little extra love and care is required but your tank will be more than mature enough to house a clam and your care levels will keep it happy too :)

My main suggestion for you with getting would be no sandbed. Buy yourself a nice flat piece of rock or a purpose built "clam disc" and place the clam on that then on the sandbed or wherever you so choose :)

Make sure you also spend a good hour or two acclimatising the new clam too. For clams I usually spend a solid hour but test the salinity difference and if its quite large take a little longer. It won't cause any harm :) I spend two hours acclimatising my big maxima when I restarted the tank.
 
Top