Green Bubble Algae

Surfnut

Active Member
I've always used superglue gel to remove GBA. Simply squeeze a ton of the gel onto the top of the GBA matt; Being careful to completely cover the surface. Allow the gel to dry, then simply grasp the hardened gel cap and gently lift the entire mass out without breaking a single bubble.
 

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
OK. I'm going to try to ride this out and just see what it's like to live with GBA in my tank. Seems like others do that. if it gets out of control, I guess it's start over time--which wouldn't be so bad if there was a good way to house my livestock while I did. Might even give me an excuse to clean up a couple of things I woud do different now that I have more experience. They need like a boarding store for fish. :)

I would imagine we are talking a couple of months to restart...maybe like 4 or 5 to really handle my current bioload. That's a long time for a cheap QT tank.
 
Last edited:

Oxylebius

Well-Known Member
Looks like my GBA problem was NOT nipped in the bud. I'm trying to decide what to do about that. Not a happy camper. I just found small bits of it basically all over my tank.

I thought some prominent folks here boiled the live rock and started over. I actually wouldn't be all that opposed to that if I had a good way to take care of my livestock while my DT was cycling etc.

Seems there is a difference between 'boiling' and 'cooking' live rock that you should look into before attempting.

Yes, some people have boiled live rock on the stovetop and some have caused themselves serious issues by doing so: http://www.advancedaquarist.com/blo...-poisoning-almost-killed-myself-wife-and-dogs. Palys or no palys, I wouldn't risk vaporizing anything that is in or on your live rock. IMHO.

Others have 'cooked' their live rock which is a different process. To cook liverock you just place it in a container in the dark. Aggresively skim, do water changes, and syphon the detritus off the bottom during water changes. Opinions on time vary anywhere from a month to several months. You don't kill everything, a lot of the bacteria on the rock survive this process so the rock is still live as far as biological filtration is concerned.
 
Last edited:

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
Thanks, Sue!

In that post I had thrown around the term "boil live rock" without really researching it or knowing what it meant. I actually did Google it since then and spotted a scary article of a person who poisoned his family doing that. Maybe the same one you cited. I'll check.

Regardless, if I was going to start over what I would really do (I think) is replace my live rock with "real reef" live rock (aka manufactured live rock). If I get serious about it, I'll research that more and ask questions.

Also, I'll have a QT and nothing will go in my tank unless it's been in the QT for 10 weeks.

I actually don't like my current live rock because the whole thing is bonded together in one piece. Means I can't fix issues without taking ALL of my live rock out. It looks cool, but makes changing anything or dealing with a location specific problem very hard.

Anyway, thanks for the heads up and trying to keep me alive and all. :)
 

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
For no clear reason, I started to feel better about my GBA issue after reading this thread. Functionally, it just sounded like people were learning to cope with it so I thought I can too. Also, the fact that I haven't seen any since my last manual removal made me upbeat.

Then I went to move one of my corals. (My favite...or is it favia?) and there was a wall of GBA all down the back of the coral. I took it out, scrubbed it off, and dipped it, but basically I think this is an issue that will get out of control it's just a matter of when.

You see, an experienced person helped me with my live rock and while he did REALLY cool stuff with it, it's basally one piece. So, if GBA develops in a spot I can't really manually remove easily (like the back of my live rock), I'm totally screwed. I can't manually remove it without removing ALL of my live rock or tearing my live rock into little pieces and somehow reconstructing, which is also very hard. I now see that it's probably basically a matter of time before that happens.

I don't think this is an "urgent" issue, but I'm going to start planning for a restart for if/when I need to. I've been googlng ideas on how to do that. i would want to make sure the tank itself is super clean. Hate to go through a restart and have residual GBA rear its head.

Any advice on what to research?
 

Frankie

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
Keep thinking you may benefit from a low nutrient system. Look into bio pellets it may be the answer to starving these bastards out
 

Frankie

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
All algae depend on two things to survive. Nutrients and light. Usually light tends to be the culprit from old bulbs shifting in spectrum. Yours are fairly new so I am thinking nutrients are the issue.
Even though you test for Po4 and get good results. The reason is usually because the algae feeding on it lowers the real value giving you false readings.
Bio Pellets provide a source for nutrient feeding bacteria to thrive helping to starve out the algae by consuming there food source.
 

Frankie

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
Do you have an opinion on bio pellets vs algae scrubbers?

http://www.santa-monica.cc
Not a big fan of algae scrubbers. Just my opinion.
It just does not comput with me the idea. I know others rave about them but for me it is about eradicating unwanted algae from the system. Not using it to control.
I understand the science behind it but don't agree.
Bio Pellets on the other hand do make sense to me. Using nutrient feeding bacteria to starve the algae out...... Now that is brilliant!
 

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
Not a big fan of algae scrubbers. Just my opinion.
It just does not comput with me the idea. I know others rave about them but for me it is about eradicating unwanted algae from the system. Not using it to control.
I understand the science behind it but don't agree.
Bio Pellets on the other hand do make sense to me. Using nutrient feeding bacteria to starve the algae out...... Now that is brilliant!

Awesome. Thanks!
 

Frankie

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
Not trying to steer you away from algae scrubbers. Just sharing my thinking.
I do believe AS work in removing nutrients. If you like a mess and dealing with regular maintenance.
Bio Pellets on the other hand are more efficient and cleaner to handle.
I really dig this one
http://www.nextreef.com/solidreactors.html
 

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
I understand. No worries. I'm aware different highly experienced folks here have different views. I value your opinion highly, but I'm aware others may say something different and that's OK by me,

Thanks for the link to the reactor. I'm currently researching for a good rector. I bought a two little fishies hang in back one and it didn't fit with the room I have (barely). So, looking for what to buy.
 

DianaKay

Princess Diana
RS STAFF
I've come to my own conclusion about GBA. It's more than likely going to be part of the SW hobby that we will be dealing with non-stop.
I've been using manual removal for 2 years and that's what I'm still doing. I've looked at the one of the GBA types I have under strong magnifying lens (See picture in post #12 this thread) & I realize when I have the tweezers out removing clusters, there are tiny bubbles that get away. They break off easily. The super glue might be good to eliminate a little bit of that??....but I hate skimmer overflow when I use superglue. :mad:
As far as low light & low nutrients, I don't think either one helps with starving out GBA.
I wish there was a miracle to eliminate GBA, just don't think the cure for it has been invented yet.
Adding a GBA eating fish is not an option in a 65 gal tank that is already at max fish limit.
So my WC for tomorrow will involve removing all GBA that I see AGAIN.
Not looking forward to it either, I hate GBA!!!!!
I've seen the nighmare it can be if you let it go, can NOT do that!!
 

Frankie

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
Sounds like you gave in Diana.
The reason I am pushing for bio Pellets is from my experience using zeovit.
Prior to using zeovit I was having big issues with algae of all sorts, including gba.
About 6 months into the program I had zero algae issues. And that was without using manual removal.
I am not recommending zeovit to Pat for several reasons. It is very advanced and I do not want to overload him with new stuff. His tank looks pretty good without it.
A low nutrient system will starve off the culprits. It will take time and energy but I believe that you can succeed if diligent.
GBA can be beaten!
That being said, I posted not to long ago that I had some on a frag (on the dark side unnoticed) that was a good size cluster.
I pulled the frag out completely, went over to the sink and scrapped it all off with a razor blade. Then I rinsed it off completely under tap water straight from the sink faucet.
I just took a look at it and it is GBA free still. That was a few weeks ago.
 

DianaKay

Princess Diana
RS STAFF
I'm just not "into" doing a lot of testing. That's why I am so religious about keeping my weekly WC routine. Everything looks great so I don't test very often.
My corals are growing faster than I want them to without dosing anything.
I'm ready to get rid of the corals that are growing faster than I want to trim them back. Monti-Caps being 1st to go.
I have no where to take frags unless I want to drive an 1hr45min to drop them off.
My nitrates have always been near 0. Maybe due to WC's or because I grow an over abundance of Chaetomorpha in my refugium. I have to trim it back more often than I like messing with it also. I throw it out with the WC water weekly.
It's fun to see pretty corals grow & fill in, then they need to STOP :D
The GBA in my tank could run out of LR room before it has a chance to take over....that might work :rolleyes: :D
 

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
I've come to my own conclusion about GBA. It's more than likely going to be part of the SW hobby that we will be dealing with non-stop.
I've been using manual removal for 2 years and that's what I'm still doing. I've looked at the one of the GBA types I have under strong magnifying lens (See picture in post #12 this thread) & I realize when I have the tweezers out removing clusters, there are tiny bubbles that get away. They break off easily. The super glue might be good to eliminate a little bit of that??....but I hate skimmer overflow when I use superglue. :mad:
As far as low light & low nutrients, I don't think either one helps with starving out GBA.
I wish there was a miracle to eliminate GBA, just don't think the cure for it has been invented yet.
Adding a GBA eating fish is not an option in a 65 gal tank that is already at max fish limit.
So my WC for tomorrow will involve removing all GBA that I see AGAIN.
Not looking forward to it either, I hate GBA!!!!!
I've seen the nighmare it can be if you let it go, can NOT do that!!

I might be OK with this philosophy except the way my live rock is put together there are LOTS of places for GBA to get out of control where I flat out can't get to it manually without completely tearing apart my tank because my live rock is all bonded together in one piece. So, I think it leaves me in a bigger quandary than folks with more easily separable live rock.

So, I'm going to try to get it under control. I'm not necessarily optimistic, but I'll happily try suggestions from folks with good ideas. I realize things that worked for others may not work or me (for example maybe because I overfeed). :). Either I'll get it under control or it'll grow where I can't manually remove it and my tank will look like a disaster and I'll restart. I'll try hard for the former and be prepared for the latter.

It's kind of a shame because otherwise I like the way my tank is looking. Most of my corals are doing really well.
 
Last edited:

Frankie

Well-Known Member
RS STAFF
@DianaKay
I understand. Testing can be quite a chore. That is why the reefing gods invented Elos test kits and Hanna ;)
You should at least be testing fully each new batch of salt bucket for consistency.
To do this, lay the bucket on its side before opening a new one and roll it around for as long as you can. (Few minutes)
This helps mix it from possible ship settling.
When you open a new bucket test it for everything.
This will give you a good idea on what is happening in your system since you are a good water changer. (Which I fully support! )
Personally I think everyone should be doing weekly 15 - 20% water changes.

As for coral growth, if to fast then something is off. The coral is growing a fast skeleton but the tissue is being stretched too thin over it. This makes for weak coral and possibly susceptible to diseases, bugs and other things that can kill the colony.
 

Pat24601

Well-Known Member
Frankie, I use Hanna Checkers for Calcium, Alkalinty, and phosphates. I'm a big fan of HC for those three...although calcium does take careful measurements.

I'm curious why you say Elos? Are those "easy"? I never tried them.

For nitrates I use Red Sea or API depending on how much I care (right now I care more than normal).
 
Top